Categorized | News

Natalie MacLean: The Controversy

Our friends at The Palate Press have posted an article named:  “Natalie MacLean: World’s Best Wine Writer or Content Thief?” They dive straight into some issues with Natalie’s publication that looks at the high probability of her stealing the content of others to build her profits. Here’s a snip:

Her website offers a paid “Magnum Membership” that gives readers access to wine reviews. It also generates revenue from advertising. The core of Ms. MacLean’s work is the publication of wine reviews and food and wine pairings. In addition to her own reviews, which are often a sentence or less, Ms. MacLean includes professional wine reviews by writers from other publications. The reviews sometimes include the writer’s name, but never the publication or a link. Rather, they are all accredited to “Vintages Wine Catalogue,” a Liquor Control Board of Ontario publication which runs fully accredited reviews, including author, date, and publication, to drive wine sales, much like any retailer on line or on shelf-talkers.

There is a simple phrase for this practice in which Ms, MacLean has engaged – copyright infringement. Just because someone is writing about wine rather than, say, politics or foreign affairs does not absolve him or her from adhering to journalistic ethics. Intellectual property theft is a scourge on journalism and cannot be tolerated.

Read the full article here:
http://palatepress.com/2012/12/wine/content-theft/

Update: Here’s a link to Natalie’s response:

 

http://www.nataliemaclean.com/blog/a-letter-to-my-readers-about-my-wine-reviews/